https://www.humanreligions.info/god_lied_in_eden.html
By Vexen Crabtree 2026
#adam_and_eve #christianity #christianity_creationism #genesis #god_lies #judaism
God itself in Genesis 2:16-17 says that if Adam eats from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, "thou shalt surely die" on the very same day, using the Hebrew mût tamût that specifically means physical death and yôm which does just mean an ordinary day. Eve repeats this in Genesis 3:2-3. The snake1 in Gen. 3:4-5 says it's not true and says that the effect is actually that they will attain knowledge of good and evil. Adam and Eve, who were already mortal (Genesis 3:22-23), ate from the tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and didn't die. They lived on to parent all of humanity. God in Gen. 3:22 admits that Adam and Eve did indeed "become as one of us, to know good and evil". God lied about death, and Satan1 told the truth.
#adam_and_eve #death #genesis #god_lies #satan
Genesis 2:16-17 says that if Adam eats from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, "thou shalt surely die". Eve repeats this in Genesis 3:2-3. The snake1 in 3:4-5 says it's not true. Adam and Eve were not immortal; they were mortal, and already going to die. We know this because in Genesis 3:22-23 it is clear that Adam is banished so that he doesn't go on to also eat from the other forbidden tree, the Tree of Life, and attain immortality. That means that Adam and Eve were, of course, not already immortal. Death wasn't the result of eating from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, nor was it even the punishment. God lied to Adam about the effects, and Satan1 told the truth.
Some apologists argue that 'death' means 'spiritual death', when Jesus is called the second Adam in 1 Corinthians 15:45-47,49,55 that implies somewhat that Adam, like Jesus, has not suffered a fate of spiritual death. Also, more importantly, the Hebrew used in the text mût tamût specifically means physical death.
#adam_and_eve #death #genesis #god_lies #satan
It is God itself in Genesis 2:16-17 who says that the day Adam eats from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, "thou shalt surely die", whilst the snake in 3:4-5 says it's not true. They eat from the tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and they live on to parent all of humanity (hence Eve is called 'mother of all living' in 3:20). God lied, and Satan told the truth.
Some argue that "you shall surely die" means in a non-literal, longer-term sense. This is because creation wasn't a literal 7-day week: days and nights themselves were created during that time, so there were no 'days' at first. And so many think that God created everything in 6 unknown periods, and the "7th day" is in fact all of the rest of existence, continuing forwards.
But by the time of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, days were very much the night-and-day rotating-Earth kind of days. God, being all knowing and having been the actual one to create days and nights, knows full well exactly what a 'day' is and still chooses to use the Hebrew word 'yôm' - which really does just mean an ordinary 'day'. It would be strange to insist that God actually meant the symbolic '7th-day' kind of period. If it did mean that, then "you shall surely day" is a meaningless threat as Adam and Eve were already going to die, as they were mortal (Gen. 3:22-23). The threat only makes sense if a day means a day.
#adam_and_eve #genesis #god_lies
The snake1 in Genesis 3:4-5 dismisses what God says, and asserts instead that if Eve eats from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, actually, she will attain knowledge, and become as gods, in knowing good and evil.
After they do eat from it, God in 3:22 admits that Adam and Eve have "become as one of us, to know good and evil". Satan told the truth.
The Sumerian myth Enki and Ninhursag, in the epic called Enki and the Sacred Mound, the goddess Ninhursag or Nintus ('Lady of Life')2 is growing eight herbs, which she has forbidden others to eat, as she is cultivating them2. Enki, her husband, breaks into the garden and eats them2. She curses him, and the herbs cause 8 deadly wounds in his body2. But actually, she doesn't want him to die, and so, creates either gods to heal those 8 wounds (one of them in Nin-ti, which is both 'rib' and 'life')2.
Note that some of explains some oddities in the Biblical version. God only tells Adam not to eat - because in the original version, it was only him who needs to be told. In the Biblical version, this is left without explanation. Eve simply isn't informed. It explains why Adam didn't actually die, which in the Bible, is simply left unexplained. The middle section doesn't mesh well, where Eve is being punished. But the Biblical version then ends with God worrying about just Adam 'extending his hand' and eating other forbidden fruits (Gen. 3:22 and banishes him from the garden. The Biblical version here simply forgets about Eve. This is because in the original, the Lady of Life is banishing Enki from her garden.
In the ancient Akkadian myth Adapa and the South Wind, written by the 14th century BCE, many centuries before Genesis was written:
“In the Akkadian myth of Adapa, Ea (the Akkadian version of Enki) deliberately gives misleading advice to Adapa, the earliest of the Sage-Kings, to cheat him out of eternal life. He tells Adapa to refuse bread and water offered to him by the gods, that it will be the bread and water of death. Actually, it's the bread and water of life. By refusing it, Adapa is doomed to die. This story antedates and parallels Yahweh denying Adam access to the Tree of Life.”
Skeptic Magazine (2009)2
The Hebrew story reads like a monotheistic reworking of an older myth whose structure was male-centered: a man eats forbidden plants, is cursed by a goddess, and is expelled from her garden. When adapted into a new theological framework, some elements were preserved (forbidden plants, a threat of death, a garden, expulsion), while others became distorted or left unexplained.